A critical look at the creation and utilization process of logic models

Abstract

Logic models as a technique have been well accepted into the discussion around increased accountability and evaluation. This research questions the appropriateness of the use of logic models for every program and mandating their use. In total, 104 sources were systematically reviewed, including theoretical discussions on the structure and use of logic models, case studies utilizing logic models, and practical application guides for logic models. A primary case study was also conducted where multiple stakeholders participated in separate development sessions where they created logic models. The findings of the primary case study are consistent with the literature synthesis in that there are definite potential benefits from developing a logic model, while there are also concerns and potential negative impacts that should be addressed.